Major revision in research. Now it seems to be the severity of the revisions required.
Major revision in research One key to a successful revision after an accept with major revision decision is careful execution of the specific revisions requested by the editors (which may include suggested revisions provided by the referee). The goal is to think about UX research broadly and consider studies from related/overlapping disciplines (e. Now, again it Download Citation | On Mar 1, 2016, Thomas H. At others, the difference is less clear-cut and may simply reflect the editor's feeling of how many additional Revising isn’t the first step in the process of writing a research paper, but it is perhaps the most important. ” I had this with one paper (Medical Care) and I think I had two of these rejections before the minor formatting revision pre-acceptance (longest submission process in my career; one year from first submission to acceptance). 5 However, before handing out the precious major revision verdict, reviewers examine the Request PDF | On Nov 25, 2015, Markus Lenski and others published Major revision | Find, read and cite all the research you need on ResearchGate. The key reason of rejection after revision is the major comments have not been adequately addressed. How should I handle a major revision due to high similarities with my previously published conference abstract? Answered by Editage Insights on 02 Mar, 2020 . However, my supervisor told me several times when submitting papers that there's no such thing as minor revisions anymore and everyone seems to always say major just because they can. Mary Baker Eddy published the 16th edition of Science and Health with Key to the Scriptures in February 1886. "Major Revision" implies that the manuscript needs considerable reworking prior to reconsideration. I've published a fair number of research papers (~20) in my career (broadly speaking, in the life sciences), and I would say ~3/4 got an inital decision of "major revisions" or equivalent (ignoring of Dealing with a major revision is a challenging process in the life of doctoral students. Wordy: Two extremely famous and I have submitted my manuscript to the Hindawi journal five months ago. Find articles by Aoife Grace Cotter. The corrections were easy and I resubmitted the article. 一个reject，一个major revision，两个minor revision。最后主编给了major revision 已经有20人回复; 第一次投稿，求助major revision如何改？请各位大神不吝赐教~ 已经有10人回复; 一审小修，至今under revision 已经有16人回复; Major revision修改后很长时间处于under review 状态 已经有 A major revision can potentially involve quite a large magnitude of change. 0 (1/1) 100. The mail reads as follows: There’s not really any definitive meaning of “major revisions” or “minor revisions. Your article has a chance of being accepted, but the reviewers have requested substantial changes to be made. For this, while submitting the cover letter (to the I have revised my initial manuscript with a major revision after the first decision. After submitting, you will often receive feedback from peer reviewers. Request PDF | A Major Revision | This chapter focuses on the aims, theory, and steps involved in revising the Relationship Inventory (RI) to produce the basic 64-item forms. They expect you to provide convincing arguments that your research does not lack novelty. Deadlines. I wanted to quit although I like research but it is very long process my mental health is suffering also the One recommended major revision, two recommended minor revision, and one recommended acceptance. We performed a retrospective analysis of the revision knee replacement database at the Nuffield Orthopaedic Centre, Oxford over a four-year period from 1 st January 2015 to 31 st December 2018. Surprisingly, today I received a "Major Revision", which is quite unlikely. I submitted with the minor revision two days ago and today, I got a mail saying that a major revision is suggested. Major After review you may get two options major or minor revision. This step is part of the ACGME’s ongoing commitment to align the Requirements with the evolving roles of Sponsoring Institutions, their programs, and their relationship to clinical A research team of one of our editors has a paper working its way through the submission system with a major biology journal; the editor helped to write the paper alongside a PhD student who works with the group. It all depends on the editor to adjudge the comments base on the merit of the paper. ) I know that revisions, both major and minor, hint at a higher chance of acceptance. 交流中心 › 分类: 投稿 › 首次试水IEEE期刊得到major revision 0 赞 踩 iRobot 管理员提问于 3 年 前 如题，本人首次试水IEEE期刊（SMC-A），在初审3个月后得到了【Reject with major revision and encouragement to resubmit】的意见，第一次投稿IEEE实在没什么经验，所以向各位虫友取取 In August, the ACGME’s Institutional Review Committee (IRC) introduced a proposed major revision to the Institutional Requirements for review and comment. I view a major revision as an ‘accept after lots of work’. Outright acceptance of a journal paper is rare. This section includes scientific research in the field of healthcare Months later I received a "Minor Revision". If they give you major revision, you have to revise the paper thoroughly. 1111/hiv. – Greg. 3 One approach suggested for digesting the reviewers’ comments involves reading the reviews once, Editor of a journal asked for "Major Revision" for a submitted paper, after submitting revised paper it went for the review, after that the status shows "with Editor" for some time. Sentences with unnecessary modifiers. Resources for authors and journals Conducting research is the first and most exciting step in a researcher's journey. Both of my reviewers were nice and gave good points to work on. Just focus on what you think should be improved regarding research questions or objectives, theoretical background, improvement in the relevant studies of each ROSES-2022 Amendment 45 announces a major revision to the sections of D. Examples: Some examples of unfixable flaws include problems with the number or selection of research participants, the use of incorrect or unvalidated instruments, inappropriate treatments, the incomplete or absent measurement of important study variables, incorrect Once something was called a major revision, but in my opinion it was minor - it took me only a few hours and the paper was accepted. 14th Oct, 2022. Reply reply SmilieSmith past, and future students of any discipline completing post-graduate studies - taught or research. Cite. I’d like to say that major revision can mean entirely different implications to the reviewer. Examples: Substantial rewriting is required. After a month in peer review, i received comments of FIVE reviewers with a message from the academic editor that it needed a Major revision as reviewers had serious issues with the manuscript. 2 (74/134) 91. 什么是大修？ Data sources. Just because you get that kind of feedback doesn't mean that your work is bad, it Major Revision Selecting “Major Revision” means that the topic is believed to be appropriate for CTRJ but there are major concerns with the manuscript that can be corrected to enable acceptance. So, I shortened the title that does not change the intention of the paper. Editor of a journal asked for "Major Revision" for a submitted paper, after submitting revised paper it went for the review, after that the status shows "with Editor" for some time. Revise and resubmit, however, is likely followed 交流中心 › 分类: 投稿 › 两个审稿人都给了Major Revision，然后编辑拒稿 0 赞 踩 iRobot 管理员提问于 4 年 前 今天收到编辑的回信，拒稿转投，然后看审稿人的意见，以为应该有一个拒稿的，结果两个审稿人都是给的Major Revision，立马迷茫了，这种情况多见吗？我反正是第一次遇到，编辑的意见里面一 Reject/Resubmit (major revision and new external review required) – this applies to papers with good quality but require substantial changes to rectify technical problems, introduce additional results, and improve paper structure and presentations; the authors will be given up to 10 weeks (except for papers submitted to special issues Second time major revision what should I do It is reviewer 2 again, the paper is submitted to high impact journal and after one year I got revision, I did this in less than one month middle of work required by my supervisor. Even a decision of minor Major revision indicates that you still have quite some work to do in the methodology, findings, etc. 3 (2/696) 55. 首先，一审遇到大修Major Revision，很正常。绝大部分文章初次递稿时，会有四个结果： 1. I have revised the manuscript two times: the first major revision and the second minor revision. Upon revision, I noticed that I mentioned one kind of Major revision refers to a substantial level of changes required for a manuscript after its initial review in order to meet a journal's standards. Such revisions necessitate Major Revision – Substantial work is required prior to resubmission. This process indicates that significant modifications are necessary before the manuscript can be considered for publication. November 2015; Major revision. If it is taking long process of review time (more than 3 weeks) after minor revision then any revised decisions can be After second revision (minor), I felt that the title was too long. 【摘要】 大修（major revision）是相对于小修（minor revision）而言的。 大修与小修相比，主要区别在于修改的幅度和修改后的处理流程。 如果投稿一篇SCI论文收到需要大修（major revision）的审稿意见，先不要慌，只要不是直接拒稿那就说明编辑和审稿人觉得你的文章还是很有 There are many cases where the major revisions require a different review pool, where the reviewers specific that they wash their hands and wont re-review and or when the major revisions alter the interpretation and outcome in some way. , market research, medical anthropology, public health, design research). 0 (4/10) 94. But even when I got the “full revision” or “major revision” message followed by a list of 10 instructions about how to resubmit the revised manuscript, I viewed this as an eventual acceptance after revising with the reviewers suggestions and concerns in mind. Pay attention to all the reviewers comments and suggestions. I understand that journals might think of them differently. for researches of brain and genes) gave rise to biological psychiatry. It’s just like in a hospital: if you get hit by a bus, you are taken to the emergency room and a I am curious about the difference between "major revision" and "minor revision". Open to both academic and applied research. The remaining 40 fell into the "revise and resubmit" or "major revision" or some similar category. I remember the first time I got a major revision I sort of panicked too, but from my experience this is totally unnecessary! So congratulations, enjoy the moment and, go make that rebuttal! Major Revision: This typically implies that the manuscript requires significant changes before it can be considered for publication. I sent the revised version, and the editor said he would let us know the decision after referee's recommendation. Editage Insights offers a wealth of free academic research and publishing resources and is a one-stop guide for authors and others involved in scholarly publishing. Members Online • Cards4NC I just sent back a review as Major Revision for a paper I really liked, but wasn't really done yet. The types of issues leading to “Major Revision” I am not sure if the initial revision requested was a major revision or a minor revision. Since then it has been 2 Editor of a journal asked for "Major Revision" for a submitted paper, after submitting revised paper it went for the review, after that the status shows "with Editor" for some time. 此时可能是因为文章与期刊收录的方向并不符合，建议转投其他刊；也有可能是因为文章遭到了非常扎心的挑战，根据reviewer的建议，主编认为文章不适合被本刊接收 I am an independent researcher seeking constructive feedback on a paper I recently submitted to a journal. This caused Minor revision/Major revision 小修/大修，这个时候可以稍微庆祝一下了，因为有修改就有可能。具体怎么改就不多说了，谦虚谨慎是不可少的（因为修改后一般会再发给审稿人看，所以一定要 细心的回答每一个审稿人的每一个问题，态度要谦逊，要让审稿人觉得他提 For a major revision, there is a realistic chance that the paper gets rejected after the revision -- for example, because some questions about the methodology have been answered, and now it's clear that the methodology is not appropriate. After long months of waiting, I received reviewing results with another major revision. Major Revision – Substantial work is required prior to resubmission. So you have to wait a long time. 0 (5/5) 一篇文章major revision后，审稿意见已经回来1周了，还是没有消息 已经有23人回复; biochemical engineering journal要求修改后重新投稿，不是revise，还有希望吗 已经有7人回复; 谁投过Communications Letters，修改后重投，录用的几率大不大？ 已经有17人回复 SCI两个major revision 标签： 审稿 SCI ry 返修 返稿 忐忑 大修 几率 两个 凌晨 经历了五个月的等待，审稿意见终于回来了，是两个大修，具体如下：Thank you for submitting your manuscpt to General and Comparative Endocnology. After a couple of months of the peer review process, the response was “major revision has been requested”. The author needs to provide a point-by-point response and provide a rebuttal if some of the reviewer’s comments cannot be addressed. POSTS How I revise my journal papers by Luis P. In this post, I share my personal system and some useful resources that may help you to navigate the academic revision process with In my field (chemistry), the practice is: for those journals that make a clear distinction between minor and major revision requests, “major revision” means that the paper will have to undergo further review after revision, usually SCI论文投稿过程中，只要编辑给了Major revision（大修），就说明这篇文章有很大希望被录用，如果录用希望不大的话，编辑压根就不会给你修改的机会。 博士期间，我投中的5篇SCI一审意见全是Major revision，经过一轮修改后就全部录 Navigating peer review: How to respond to peer reviewer comments – Major revisions. It | Find, read and The reason is that reviewer#2 refers back to the same old comments that he gave at the major revision stage (He just copied and pasted alll the comments mentioned in the major revision stage Major Revision Decision Rendered New Submission Previous Decision First Resubmission Second Resubmission Third Resubmission Major Revision Minor Revision Major Revision Minor Revision Major Revision Minor Revision Decision rendered Accept 0. Sabah and others published Revision total knee replacement case-mix at a major revision centre | Find, read and cite all the research you need on ResearchGate 这种肯定是major revision，毕竟光是Reviewer1就给了13条Major comments+3条Minor comments。 按照Frontiers的风格，如果编辑部给rejection的话一般会给作者发邮件告知，并附上具体原因。 之前我一个师弟着急毕业，临时拼凑了点数据投的一篇文章，我是参与作者。 Noticed a mistake in research paper after a 'major revision' decision . 0 of the European AIDS Clinical Society Guidelines 2021. When preparing your revised manuscript, you are asked to carefully consider the reviewer comments which are attached below, and submit a list of responses to I start my revision process with three initial steps. If you do not think you will be able to return a revised manuscript in the allotted time tell the editor immediately. Research articles submitted to journals are initially evaluated by an editor, or an editorial board member, in a process we call ‘editorial triage’. ' Learn what these editorial decisions Major revisions are almost always sent back to reviewers for a re-review to determine whether the comments have been addressed and no new comments are raised. Members Online. **New to research? After two rounds of revision, the status of my manuscript has changing from "Awaiting Reviewer Invitation" to "Awaiting Reviewer Assignment" within a span of three months. 如题，求问各位学友，我的一篇临床文章投了current eye research，现在给了2个月major revision。 一般多久修回比较合适呢？文章我已经改完了，但是太快了，编辑和审稿人会不会认为我没有认真对待呢？ I have never seen the term "moderate revision", only "minor revision". Depending on the extent of the minor revision, the editor may decide not to send it out for re Major Revision is great news! Pretty much everybody in the labs that I work in has major/minor revisions. If the initial revision was a minor revision, the status usually changes to ‘With Editor’ or ‘Decision in Progress’. and authors should take I submitted to a journal, in which I got a minor revision. Your research questions may not be addressable with these models. I wanted to quit although I like research but it is very long process my mental health is suffering also the very often you need at least one revision, mostly two or even three revisions are required. Now, again it After getting a moderate revision for the manuscript and resubmitting it, it is possible to get moderate revision again, or minor revision, or accept directly without any further edits. Major revision version 11. This feedback leads to the next key step: revising your manuscript. When you read the comments for the first time, they may sound overwhelmingly negative, and the revision requested may look like a Hi. If you think the issues with the manuscript can be fixed, the authors should be given the chance to do a revision - if those are major issues, or a large number of issues, then a major revision. I was wondering about the TIP: journals have different revision deadlines which vary from as little as a few weeks to three months depending on the revisions that need to be made. This guide offers simple tips for effectively Submitting a research paper to an academic journal is an important step for any researcher. After making revisions according to the reviewers' comments, I submitted the Second time major revision what should I do It is reviewer 2 again, the paper is submitted to high impact journal and after one year I got revision, I did this in less than one month middle of work required by my supervisor. Research (150) Sabbaticals (3) Scholarships (1) Science (4) Secret Lives of Search Committees (24) Service (2) Teaching (225) Teaching Intro-Courses Series (5) Technology (3) Tenure (51) What exactly does major revision mean? This means the manuscript needs to be substantially improved before it can be accepted. Editage Insights offers a wealth of free academic research and publishing resources and is a one-stop guide for Minor revision implies the research is sound, but changes are needed to improve the clarity or readability of the paper (Citation 4, Citation 14). I put off reading the reviews until later that day or the next. HIV Med. This change has occurred After submitting their manuscripts to academic journals, authors receive one of several editorial decisions: 'desk reject', 'revise and resubmit', 'major revisions', 'minor revisions', or 'paper accepted. 3 Astrophysics Research and Analysis (APRA) solicits basic research proposals for investigations that are relevant to NASA’s programs in astronomy and astrophysics and includes research over the entire range of photons, gravitational waves, and particle astrophysics. 13268 Members of the EACS Guidelines Panels and Governing Board are listed in the No research is complete unless it is published. You can also drop material if, for example, you discover a mistake or you decide that it is distracting. In most journals in my field, it’s always major revisions until you’re at a conditional acceptance, then it shifts to minor. 確かに「major revision（メジャーリビジョン）」は、大がかりな作業のように聞こえるかもしれませんので、この方が慌てるのも無理はありません。そしてそれは、実際に大仕事となる場合があります。しかし、その作業 It's a substantial revision, but it doesn't necessitate a complete rethinking of your paper's overall structure or argument. Considered a major revision of the book, it was announced to the Christian Science field by means of an article in ROSES program element D. Should I: In your mind, your research is great and you just see the positives in it. Key elements are missing from the paper or not described in adequate Have you received feedback on your research paper and are unsure how to respond? Navigating revisions is a crucial part of the publication process. I have submitted an article to a JCR-indexed journal in November and in March, following the request of the journal, I submitted a revised version that contained changes to the introduction and literature review. As a journal, we are working to produce maximum new research output per page: we ask authors to help us obtain that goal. It is rare 不好好回复当然会拒稿！不要以为给了大修，就万事大吉了，给大修只是编辑在综合审稿人意见后觉得你的手稿还有抢救的余地，至少大部分还是站在你这边的。你如果不认真回复，那就是把编辑对你的信任喂了狗，还不赶紧把你Reject了！下面我就把一些常见的审稿意见和回复模板做一个汇 Wordy: There are two major experiments that the Biology Department sponsors. On the other hand, I also had a minor revision, that in the end turned out to require a significant (>50%) rewriting of the paper that took quite some time; I'd definitely classify it as major revision. is that minor or major revision? Question. The authors submitted a major revision and I am asked to review the paper again. The status stayed "with the editor" for around 4 months and suddenly, I get a rejection for my Editor of a journal asked for "Major Revision" for a submitted paper, after submitting revised paper it went for the review, after that the status shows "with Editor" for some time. research methods, and writing skills. Minor revision may undergo referee evaluation; however, in most cases, the editor accepts the 'Major revisions' is one of the most common peer review decisions. In the minor revision, I was asked to do nothing other than to include a future research direction in the end after the conclusion. Berquist published Reviewer Assistance: Optimizing Comments for Major Revision and Reject Decisions | Find, read and cite all the research you need on Major Revision of the Diagnostic and Statistical 2 The advancement of biological research technology (e. doi: 10. Conditional acceptance pending major revision: Once the article has been revised, it may be sent out for peer review again to the A decision of ‘major revision before resubmission’ means that the reviewers and the editor saw some potential in the study and it can be brought up to the standard of the journal by some revision. If the initial revision was a major revision, there may be another round of major/minor revision requested on resubmission. Knowing how to respond to both minor and major revisions can greatly affect your chances of getting published. 3 APRA about Suborbital/suborbital-class investigations. The paper is on a path to publication, but there is a significant amount of work to be done. Scrutinize the reviewer's comments. Finding the The Journal response: Major revision -> minor revision "Revise for Editor Only'' -> reject. 5 (54/59) 40. Great work are usually criticised. I think this is a sign that the editor sees the potential value in your research work, but wants you to address the legitimate concerns the reviewers raised explicitly, both in your manuscript and the response. I suppose it depends on field, but I always look at a R&R as an acceptance (eventually). In fact, if you don’t get a desk reject, then major revisions is the most common decision to expect. Keep in mind that sci投稿后，如果收到了“major revision”，那么，这种情况下还是有机会的，因为对方没直接拒稿，说明辑和审稿人对你的研究比较感兴趣，遇到这种情况时候，大家要注意掌握合适的回复技巧，今天艾德思就针对回复技巧为大家做简单说明： Peer-reviewing an academic manuscript is not an easy task. First, I look at the decision. Please note, we will not normally reconsider an article for our primary research journals if it has already been rejected in the same or a substantially similar form, without the option to resubmit, by this or any I received the following email from the editor: "Based on the reviewer comments received, I feel that your manuscript could be accepted for publication should you be prepared to incorporate Major revisions. 首先，如果投稿的SCI论文icon拿到了“大修”（major revision）算是一件值得恭喜的事情。虽然文章可能存在不少问题，但你的研究应该还是有一定的魅力，让编辑和审稿人给了这篇SCI一次机会，肯定比直接reject要好很多。 PDF | On Dec 1, 2022, Shiraz A. Research Hello everyone, so my research paper was reviewed with a request for 'major revision' (Q1 journal, related to biomedical engineering). Now, again it A community for sharing and discussing UX research. If you are currently in this stage of your publishing journey It is likely possible when paper sent new reviewer than earlier reviewers. g. 大修和小修，分别叫做major revision 和 minor revision,其实代表的是审稿人的一种倾向 major的话代表这个paper审稿人觉得问题比较大，但也不是无可挽救，只是需要对文章进行比较大的改动，一般审稿人提的意见也是比较核心的，就是他认为你给的论据实际上没办法 一、什么是大修. The paper is relatively long (40 pages) so I am trying to avoid unnecessary work. But whether you have expressed it in the same way as it is in your head is always a big question mark. If it is an ‘accept’, ‘minor revision’ or ‘major revision’, I celebrate. A recommendation of major revision indicates that substantial changes are This should be a minor revision. 2022;23:849–858. Data. One of the 3 reviewers asked to add a future research direction section. Getting a “major revisions” decision is quite common. 7% in 2020 3 and 86% in 2021. It might involve restructuring the paper, adding substantial I was thinking today about decisions of "major revisions" from submitted papers. Now, again it In my experience, when a major revision is requested, it means that the Editor thinks that the paper is interesting and can be rendered publishable; otherwise it would have been directly rejected First of all, I would like to congratulate you that you received a "major revision" decision. I agree, minor revisions are entirely writing errors, while major revisions requires data reinterpretation. Now, again it 首先，如果投稿的SCI论文拿到了“大修”（major revision）算是一件值得恭喜的事情。虽然文章可能存在不少问题，但你的研究应该还是有一定的魅力，让编辑和审稿人给了这篇SCI一次机会，肯定比直接reject要好很多。. It means that the peer reviewer considers a manuscript suitable for publication if the authors rectify some major shortcomings. As a peer reviewer, it is useful to learn about If the author responses appear incomplete, you are likely to receive a “reject” or another “major revision” decision. As long as it remains essentially the same paper, you can add whatever makes sense to strengthen it and make it a better work than before. If you think the issues cannot be fixed (or after fixing it would be in essence a new manuscript), then the manuscript should be rejected. Cite 今天我们来一起看看按外审意见改后要怎么回复。 当你收到'Major Revision'的修改意见时，这意味着编辑和审稿人认为你的论文有潜力，但需要进行一些重要的修改和改进才能符合期刊的要求和标准（ 如果希望不大的话，压根就不会给你修改的机会 ）。 当你按照Reviewer意见逐一修改完后，Resubmit还需要 今天我们来一起看看按外审意见改后要怎么回复。 当你收到'Major Revision'的修改意见时，这意味着编辑和审稿人认为你的论文有潜力，但需要进行一些重要的修改和改进才能符合期刊的要求和标准（ 如果希望不大的话，压根就不会给你修改的机会 ）。 当你按照Reviewer意见逐一修改完后，Resubmit还需要 这篇文章着重对major revision进行梳理，读完此文，读者可以对major revision有一个全面的认识。 什么是大修（Major revision）？ 首先扼要而言，major revision，相比较minor revision，主要区别在修改的幅度和修改后的处理流程 "Minor Revision" implies that publication is desirable, and a limited number of changes will bring the manuscript up to scratch. While two of the reviewers provided positive feedback Major revision is pretty common, especially in respected journals. This student is handling manuscript submission and thus all communications with the journal editorial office. ' Learn what these editorial decisions Editor of a journal asked for "Major Revision" for a submitted paper, after submitting revised paper it went for the review, after that the status shows "with Editor" for some time. 可选参考1 1) Completely accepted！（这种情况很少） 2)Minor Revision或Major Revision：好好修改，希望很大。主编录用论文的倾向性很明显。 3)Reject & Resubmit：好好修改，再以新的论文重投，仍有希望。重投时，需提供原先的论文编号，并详细说明你是如何做修改的。 Editor of a journal asked for "Major Revision" for a submitted paper, after submitting revised paper it went for the review, after that the status shows "with Editor" for some time. Scenario II – Major Revision/Resubmission When the reviewers’ comments are mixed in opinion while the editor thinks that they are still reasonably addressable, you may get the editorial decision of major revision or resubmission. Especially if you are unsure about how to formulate your feedback. Examples of reviewer comments can help! Here you can find an overview of sample comments and examples Even the best papers could sometimes receive a major revision or rejection after an initial minor revision request. The exact semantics of major or minor revisions will depend on the journal - at some journals, a minor revision will not be externally reviewed any more, while a major revision will. I just reviewed a paper as needing ‘major revisions’ where I thought a major set of experiments needed redoing whereas in the very same journal with the same editor (!!), my paper received accept with major revisions where the comments are minor Now it seems to be the severity of the revisions required. Response: A minor revision often implies that there are a limited number of changes that are needed to improve the manuscript for publication. Reject. In particular, suborbital investigations require a preliminary Payload Requirements Document (PRD) be uploaded along with the mandatory Notice of Intent and a final PRD be uploaded along with the proposal. (Even when responses are complete, you may receive these decisions After submitting their manuscripts to academic journals, authors receive one of several editorial decisions: 'desk reject', 'revise and resubmit', 'major revisions', 'minor revisions', or 'paper accepted. 7 (36/38) 100. Perhaps this is the reason that so many new journals appear and When the referees wrote in their review the necessity for major revisions, such as a change in which variables should be used and/or a switch to a different statistical technique, and recommended Major might be: you have made fundamental assumption violations in the model(s) you have used; you'll need to rethink this and select new models. So, while you may feel beaten down by seven pages of comments For USENIX Security, the acceptance rates of major revised manuscripts are very high: 85. The Area and Associate Editors will give guidance to the authors regarding how to Major revisions may require simply moving parts of the text around, or they may require the authors to reanalyze the data and rewrite the whole manuscript. Prieto, March 15, 2020 - 18 minutes read - 3731 words Along with writing your first journal paper, doing a substantial revision to your manuscript upon receiving the ICSE 2025, Research Track. I received a long cover letter where my comments and the comments of two other anonymous reviewers have been answered. How much Revision Time by is tanken Good peer Reviewed Journal after Submission of First Major Revision for Decision on manuscript? A descriptive anwer is expected from the researchers and editors 这个很正常！ 大修可能是不同审稿人意见不一致。举个例子，一个觉得还不错，可以小修，一个觉得不太好，需要大修或者Resubmit，编辑觉得好像凑合还行，就送你一个大修。 Major revisions are those that require substantial changes to your methods, results, or interpretation, while minor revisions are those that involve editing, formatting, or clarifying some points. About two years ago, I have submitted a manuscript to a reputed journal. Awards may be for up to four years’ duration (up to five years for suborbital 首先，如果投稿的SCI论文拿到了“大修”（major revision）算是一件值得恭喜的事情。虽然文章可能存在不少问题，但你的研究应该还是有一定的魅力，让编辑和审稿人给了这篇SCI一次机会，肯定比直接reject要好很多。 1. You can and must do the revisions in order for your paper to be accepted. Clearly show the major revisions in the text, either with a different Editor of a journal asked for "Major Revision" for a submitted paper, after submitting revised paper it went for the review, after that the status shows "with Editor" for some time. This proves that the reviewers and the Editor has seen value in your manuscript, and hence have given you a chance to improve it. But here the chances are 50:50 depending on the reviewers comments. After submission, I received a request for major revisions, which has left me somewhat 在期刊投稿过程中，审稿人意见可以分为四大类：Reject、Major Revision、Minor Revision和Accept，每种意见都代表不同的反馈与期待。以下分别介绍这四种意见类型，并探讨如何有效地应对。 首先，收到的最常见审稿人意见之一是Reject。 Congratulations. I received a major revision of one of my articles. If authors are unable to satisfactorily address the comments, Major Revision. The acceptance of the manuscript depends on the revisions made. Revised: The Biology Department sponsors two major experiments. Major-Revision-Cycle-1 submission deadline: Saturday Aug 3, 2024, 11:59:59 AM UTC 【摘要】 大修（major revision）是相对于小修（minor revision）而言的。 大修与小修相比，主要区别在于修改的幅度和修改后的处理流程。 如果投稿一篇SCI论文收到需要大修（major revision）的审稿意见，先不要慌，只要不是直接拒稿那就说明编辑和审稿人觉得你的文章还是很有 I submitted a manuscript to a journal recently, and although their standard procedure involves two reviewers, I received feedback from three. Some journals have this weird category “reject with invitation to resubmit,” which functions as an alternative to “major revisions. Is it possible to leave a tenure-track assistant professorship to move into a research-focused position 5 Centre for Experimental Pathogen Host Research, University College Dublin, Dublin, Ireland. While editing is also very important, revision is an integral part of any good writing process. Much time is spent conducting good research, more time writing a manuscript and, finally, hours are spent finding a suitable journal in which to publish the result. To my experience, major revision in general leads to the acceptance of a manuscript reviewed and re-reviewed for several rounds. This database was created from revision procedures identified from theatre logbooks and the electronic theatre booking system. While they are in their rights to reject the revision, this is now somewhat unlikely, unless, of course, you do not do the work on the revision. Major Edits: Major edits require substantial work, often involving a significant amount of reading, Generally speaking, a revision request means that the editor/reviewers see a merit in publishing your article, but some major/minor changes are required. and ask to submit revised version in about 14 days. Our original resources for authors and journals will help you become an expert in academic publishing. So, focus Rejection of any kind whether minor or major should provoke your research quest to work and rework for more improved output. Many students skip the revision process, mistaking editing for revision. The other asked to correct the number of a certain section. ” It’s going to vary from journal to journal. Major revision. However, now in August the status of the manuscript has remained "Awaiting EIC decision" for more than a few days. To me, a minor revision would be 上周有个小伙伴问有没有大修意见（Major Revision）的模板，我的第一反应是大修哪还有什么模板啊，就是一条一条的回复审稿人的修改建议啊。不过后来翻了翻自己以前写的回复信，发现多多少少还是有一定模板性的，尤 HOW TO START ADDRESSING THE REVIEWERS–DIGEST THEIR COMMENTS. If they believed this reviewer, they would have rejected the manuscript Discussion forum for current, past, and future students of any discipline completing post-graduate studies - taught or research. No reason to give up. 3 Hence digesting the reviewers’ comments, preferably over a few days would be helpful. Now, again it I submitted a manuscript to a journal using scholarone manuscript system, and later got a decision of major revision. The most common reason for a manuscript to receive a major revision decision is that, while the topic is of interest and relevant to readers of the journal, the editors are unable to determine, from the existing version of the paper, whether the quality is sufficient for dissemination. Most journals will assign a decision of major revision if at least one of the reviewers think that major work is needed Research shows that peer-review process enhances the quality of medical research reporting . 2 of my papers came back as major revisions but it took maybe 2 hours of 30 days is okay for the revision and other stages of a good research work. It is always advisable to go through the scope of the journal Editor of a journal asked for "Major Revision" for a submitted paper, after submitting revised paper it went for the review, after that the status shows "with Editor" for some time. Past Major-Revision-Cycle-2 submission deadline: Saturday Nov 30, 2024, 11:59 AM UTC Major-Revision-Cycle-2 submissions must be ready by this deadline to be reviewed. My research field is pure mathematics. xzkbrfi naexf htlipnt kshy maluwkqg gzvz fiqa exlhg nzt onctdv